Top Notch!

The third paragraph of this review is one of the best bits of writing I have read and sums up the map perfectly.

Awesome work Glassman!! not only does it looks good,but it plays great. thanks

Glassman shows id how Gothic *should* be done.

What a fucking amazing map.

congrats on making PQ's LotW, Glassman! well deserved!

and DEMO, i never thought i'd say this about anyone, but - my wife is actually starting to make more sense than you. :o>

The atmosphere was so good that I wanted to say I crapped myself several times whilst playing it (though I'd be lying). Excellent map. No doubt about it. I especially liked the stain glass window projection on the wall from the light coming in through that window; that is something I've never seen done before.

Uh, I never actually downloaded it because I was too busy critisising others :rolls eyes at himself, but remebers he needs mirror to see them:. I'll grab it now and see how nice it is.

Keep your panties on ladies.

It's a great map. Can we leave it at that? :)

wow, thanks for clearing that up, DEMO. :rolls eyes:

Spooky, Spooky, Spooky. I've had this map for a few weeks and it still creeps me out. Just the atmosphere is worh the download (and I thought the ID maps were gothic). But then again, what do I know...

Awsome map GlassMan. Been playing it for a couple of weeks now, and it still rocks.

Congrats

I just feel 'cat and mouse' doesn't really fit a review on a map. Plus 'cat and mouse', as you described it, happens a lot of times in battle because you chase someone you see out of the corner of your eyes for a while. So this really makes it a gameplay theme in all maps IMO.

"And the architect mentioning in this review seems to try to give a very good visual on what the map looks like before you play it."

I believe you were quoting there just to try and get back at me? Since you think that quote makes no sense, I shall explain: "architect mentioning" = when someone metions architecture on something. "Very good visual on what the map looks like before you play it." = the reviewer has gone into such detail that he seems to be trying to giving us a 'seeing' before we play the map, so that we know what we're in for to a certain extent.

Enough said... *retains himself from saying anything more argumental*

hehe, and this makes sense, {DEMO}?

"And the architect mentioning in this review seems to try to give a very good visual on what the map looks like before you play it."

riiiiight.

'cat and mouse' was a bad analogy. my fraggin' buddies and i use that term when we find ourselves hunting each other down and scaring the living crap out one another.

a great map nonetheless.

Thanks for all the comments & thx pjw I'm honoured!

I agree the gameplay may not be to everyone's taste - the map's history conspired against good layout planning. It started as a segment from a single player map I made for Quake (as in quake 1). My original plan was for 1v1 but it got a little too big for that so I added the quad and made it a little larger still in the hope that small ffa's & 2v2 would be fun.

waY2Kool, in regards to your gameplay review, 'great cat & mouse fun' is gobblety gook to me. All that says is that 1v1 gives one player chasing another, which after all happens to a certain extent if you play 1v1 defensively (like I often do). A real gameplay review would give comments on which items are where because that makes good gameplay, and which places link to other places to give good gameplay etc.

Outstanding map. Haven't played it enough yet to say much about gameplay, but the aesthetics are really sweet. It's now the latest addition to the Kickass Maps list on my site.

http://pjw.planetquake.gamespy.com/maps.html#kickass

oof, glad you cleared that up in the end with your 'moral' :)

it's really not hard to review the gameplay tho. we play with 3-4 ppl. which is about perfect, i wouldn't put 5-6 in here tho - it's too tight for that. 1 on 1 is awesome - great cat & mouse fun, with guaranteed jump-out-of-your-seat action.

Gameplay is sorta hard to review about if you think of it; it isn't really that easy to go into detail with how gameplay works (if you do it'll be a boring piece). But I do agree, a review just isn't complete without any mention of gameplay. And the architect mentioning in this review seems to try to give a very good visual on what the map looks like before you play it.

Moral of this story: if you don't like the reviews here, do them yourself; LvL needs reviews big time.

yes, the visuals and atmosphere are superb. the gameplay is quite good too and we play it regularly. nice work Glassman.

a keeper all the way.

I agree with LH

where are reviews of gameplay... seems to be that all 'J f z' cares about is visuals.

nice, but not a keeper

Fine job, I'm always finding a new hidey hole to peck from. We have made this one of our lunchtime regulars.

Amazing map! Love it!

Gameplay is ok... not as good as in GlassMans first map.

The looks are incredible, and the map is certainly worth a dl for the aesthetics alone.

9/10

best gothic map ever!

Gameplay is excelelnt too, one of those rare must have maps.

Umm, What about the gameplay in the review? The entire thing is about the appearance.